Camino de Guadalupe
The Guadalupan Event · Chapter 3 of 15
The Guadalupan Event
Chapter 3

An Orphaned People

Watch the video

Video in Spanish with English subtitles.

Read the chapter

Full text organized by topic.

Start reading ↓

Guadalupan Backpack

Resources for guides and catechists.

Go to the Backpack ↗

Today you will discover: The spiritual orphanhood of the Indigenous people, and Guadalupe as the Mother who hears their weeping, heals their sorrows and offers a sacred little house.

Central idea: The Conquest left a deep wound: many felt they had lost their face, their heart and their home. Guadalupe came as a Mother to console, heal and gather.

What does it mean to you to feel alone or without support?

The video is in Spanish. To watch it with English subtitles, start the video, click the CC (subtitles) button and, under Settings ⚙ › Subtitles/CC, choose English. If it does not play here, open it directly on YouTube and turn on English subtitles there.

A little over 500 years ago, when the expedition of Juan de Grijalva explored the coast of Veracruz in 1518, one of the sights that most impressed the Spaniards was the island they named “of Sacrifices,” because on arrival they witnessed the way this ritual was performed, which they immediately described as barbaric and bloodthirsty. When the Spaniards reached Mexico, they found a civilization whose religion was very different from Christianity. What struck the conquistadors most was the powerful state religion that worshiped the main Indigenous deities through human sacrifices accompanied by various rites. With the mindset of sixteenth-century Europeans, they saw it as a demonic religion and set out to destroy it completely and to root out every form of idolatry.

In this chapter
01

The meeting of two worlds

On the day 1 Serpent of the year 3 House, equivalent to August 13, 1521, the feast of Saint Hippolytus, the Indigenous world with all its culture and values, the so-called “Fifth Sun,” set forever, despite the torrents of blood offered for decades to feed it. The later death of the Aztec emperor contributed to this society’s loss of trust in its gods: with the death of Moctezuma, not only the head of state disappeared but also the protector of the Children of the Sun. With the military victory over Mexico-Tenochtitlan, a systematic destruction of everything connected with the Aztec religion began at once. The Spaniards, with rare exceptions among some Franciscan friars who were beginning their work of evangelization, were unable to recognize in the defeated people the richness and values of their civilization. In a very short time Mexico-Tenochtitlan was reduced to ruins and humiliation.

02

The fall of the Fifth Sun

For the survivors, the worst thing was not having lost the war but having lost the meaning of life. The cosmos, the order of the world, had changed. The Aztec worldview, centered on and governed by the deities, had lost its foundation. Where were the gods who had protected them so well? They had abandoned them to their fate, turned their backs on them, ignored them. Octavio Paz comments in The Labyrinth of Solitude: “The drama of a consciousness that sees everything around it collapse, and first of all its gods, the creators of its people’s greatness. (…) Cuauhtémoc and his people die alone, abandoned by friends, allies, vassals and gods. Orphaned.”

03

A people without certainties

The fall of the Aztec empire was followed by an existential depression among its survivors and by a search for identity and for reasons to go on living in that world of chaos and confusion. Ángel María Garibay and Miguel León-Portilla collected some poems from the years after the defeat. The first was written less than two years after the Conquest and reads: “Weep, my friends, understand that with these events we have lost the Mexica nation. The water has turned sour, the food has turned sour! This is what the Giver of Life has done in Tlatelolco.” In the midst of this situation, this psychological, spiritual and vital orphanhood, the message of the Gospel did not take root among the Indigenous people. Many preferred death to adopting a religion “without roots, without foundation,” since for them only what had its origin in their ancestors was true.

The main tactic the friars began to use to bring the Indigenous people to Christianity was to take young boys from their families, instruct them far from home and then send them back, because “we will never truly be able to make God known to them as long as we have not torn out by the roots everything that smells of the old religion of their ancestors” (Fray Diego Durán, History of the Indies.

) This was always done in complete good faith, and at the time it was considered love for the Indigenous people, since it seemed urgent to snatch them from the clutches of the Devil and “compel them to come in” to the flock of Christ. But we can imagine the blow it dealt to their social fabric when their own children, under the protection of Spanish swords, undermined and tore down the very foundation of the Mexican family: sacred respect for the authority of their elders and loyalty to them. “There are no people in the world, nor have there ever been, who honored their elders with more fear and reverence than these, and so those who showed irreverence to the old, or to fathers and mothers, paid for it with their lives. And so what these people urged on their children and taught them was to revere the elderly of every kind, rank and condition.” (Fray Diego Durán, History of the Indies)

04

The difficulties of the first evangelization

It is true that God’s supernatural grace could help some privileged souls, as Juan Diego undoubtedly was among others, to overcome all the clumsiness with which the message was presented and to turn to Him sincerely. But for the great mass of the Indigenous people, that conversion meant nothing less than renouncing themselves: “denying their gods and the law of their ancestors; and even though they were overwhelmed by a thousand calamities, beaten and fearful, they were too aware of their dignity and greatness to renounce them, and since they felt they had lost them forever, they preferred to die rather than stop being Indian.” This explicit ideological opposition to their spiritual conquest is little known, but it happened, and it was recorded in many testimonies of the time. That is why it was so necessary for God himself to intervene with his wonderful way of teaching, as Bishop Zumárraga himself asked in the famous letter he sent to Emperor Charles V in August 1529.

Without God’s direct help, it would have been very difficult for a sound evangelization to take place and for the foundations of what would become a new society to be laid, both spiritually and in civil and social order.

05

Why Tepeyac?

And why did the Virgin choose to appear on Tepeyac? On that hill a goddess had long been worshiped: Tonantzin, which means “our revered mother,” “our dear little mother.” Many pilgrimages and offerings were made to her, but she too had become deaf and mute to her children’s pleas after the fall of Tenochtitlan. What is more, Captain General Hernán Cortés himself destroyed the idols on Tepeyac hill, including Tonantzin, wiping out the ancient “diabolical” idolatrous cult. Perhaps the Virgin Mary wished to rescue the Indigenous people from their orphanhood and abandonment, and to show herself on this very hill in order to give a new and true meaning to the veneration that took place there. Just as she did through the messages encoded in the tilma, she would also raise the chosen site to a higher meaning. Now the one who is the true Mother, not of stone but of flesh and blood, wishes to be present there.

And not only our mother, but the Mother of the very true God, by whom we live. Besides recovering and restoring the place where the Indigenous people felt the maternal love of their deity, she would tell them: “I am honored to be your compassionate mother, yours and that of all the people who live together in this land, and of all the other peoples of different ancestries, those who love me, those who cry out to me, those who seek me, those who trust in me.”

06

The Mother who gives back face and heart

Knowing that inner suffering, that feeling of having lost a mother, she addresses these very words to Juan Diego, which take on greater meaning when we understand the psychological situation this people, abandoned by its gods, was going through: “Because there I will truly listen to their weeping, their sadness, to remedy and heal all their different sorrows, their miseries, their pains.” The Virgin wants a sacred little house to be built as the new home of her children, Indigenous and Spanish alike, where she will be the Mother who cares for us and teaches us at this crucial moment in history. The message received from Mary in 1531 changed the destiny of a defeated people and became the seed of what we know today as Mexico. The Guadalupan message lies at the origin of the new mestizo nation.

Very soon after the apparitions, Tepeyac became the largest center of pilgrimage and Marian devotion in Mexico, and later one of the most important in the world. At Tepeyac a new Genesis takes place: a new creation, a new humanity whose face is the one portrayed by the mestiza Virgin Mary of Guadalupe.

07

Important points

The apparitions of the Virgin of Guadalupe on Tepeyac hill in 1531 mark a turning point in the history of the Mexican nation’s search for justice and, at the same time, for identity. It was not only a religious event, but also a political, social and cultural one.
Octavio Paz states that Guadalupe captivated everyone’s heart and imagination, to the point of making December 12 the central date in the emotional calendar of the Mexican people.
With the coming of the Virgin of Guadalupe, a new harmony is established in the Mexican worldview. She gives back a face and a heart to the inhabitants of these lands: she restores their dignity and their own identity.

The light of Tepeyac

08

Glossary

Mestizo

A term for a person whose parents are of different races, especially a white man and an Indigenous woman, or an Indigenous man and a white woman. In the Americas most of the population is mestizo because of the mixing of Indigenous, European and African peoples that began in the sixteenth century.

Isla de Sacrificios (Island of Sacrifices)

It is a Mexican island in the Gulf of Mexico, very close to the port of Veracruz. Bernal Díaz del Castillo describes his arrival at the island this way: “And going on farther we saw another island somewhat larger than the others, about a league and a half from land, and in front of it there was a good anchorage, and the general ordered us to anchor. When the boats had been lowered into the water, Juan de Grijalva went with many of us soldiers to see the islet, because there was smoke on it, and we found two houses built of stone and mortar, well made, and in each house some steps leading up to what looked like altars, and on those altars they had idols of evil shape, which were their gods. And there we found five Indians who had been sacrificed that night; their chests had been opened and their arms and thighs cut off, and the walls of the houses were covered in blood.

We were greatly astonished at all this, and we named this islet ‘of Sacrifices,’ and so it appears on the sea charts.”

Curious facts

Did you know…

Fernando de Alva Ixtlilxóchitl (1568–1648), in his Historical Works, recounts an episode of a supposed conversion: “Queen Tlacoxhuatzin, mother of Ixtlilxóchitl (the principal lord of the land of Potonchán, who was a friend of Cortés together with his chiefs and lords), being Mexica and somewhat hardened in her idolatry, did not want to be baptized and had gone to a temple in the city with some lords.

Ixtlilxóchitl went there and begged her to be baptized; she scolded him and spoke to him very harshly, saying that she did not want to be baptized and that he was a madman to deny so quickly his gods and the law of his ancestors. Seeing his mother’s determination, Ixtlilxóchitl became very angry and threatened to burn her alive if she would not be baptized, giving them many good reasons until he persuaded her and brought her to the church with the other lords to be baptized; and he burned the temple where she had been and razed it to the ground.”

A fact…

When “the Twelve” Franciscans charged with evangelization arrived in Mexico, Cortés required the Indigenous lords to attend their first catechesis, which was given through an interpreter.

At the end of the first session, they concluded as follows:

“If you wish to see and marvel at this kingdom and the riches of the one through whom we all live, our Lord Jesus Christ, above all things it is very necessary for you to despise and loathe, cast away, abhor and spit on those whom you now hold as gods and worship, for in truth they are not gods but deceivers and mockers; and it is also very necessary for you to turn away from and cast off all sins of whatever kind, for all of them anger Jesus Christ; and you must also purify yourselves of all your filth with the water of God.”

(The Dialogues of 1524, according to the text of Fray Bernardino de Sahagún and his Indigenous collaborators. Study and notes by Miguel León-Portilla. UNAM, Mexico, 1986)

Guadalupan Backpack · Assessment

Check what you have learned

Download (Spanish PDF) ← Previous chapter Next chapter → Guadalupan Resources
Juanito